Oh wow. That’s a big question. (Zelda, Tetris,…) They can do no wrong, really. I’ll give you my favorite from each album (not including the Christmas albums or EPs), and that’s probably as close as I can come to answering the question.

Relient K: Softer to Me
The Anatomy of the Tongue and Cheek: Failure to Excommunicate
Two Lefts Don’t Make a Right: Trademark
MMHMM: Which to Bury, Us or the Hatchet and Life After Death and Taxes
Five Score and Seven Years Ago: I’m Taking You With Me and Faking My Own Suicide
The Bird and the Bee Sides: Curl Up and Die and The Lining Is Silver
Forget and Not Slow Down: Candlelight

I hope that’s sufficient! I’m also really excited for the new cover album coming out this month. What’s your favorite song(s)?